Dice & Strategy

What is a cocked die?

A cocked die is one that lands tilted instead of flat, leaning on a book, a miniature, another die or the wall of the tray, so no face is clearly up. The usual rule is simple: it doesn’t count, so re-roll that die.

“Cocked” means tilted or set at an angle, as in a cocked head. A die is cocked when it comes to rest propped up on something instead of lying on one face, so the top is a ridge or a corner rather than a single number. You can’t say for certain which face is “up”, and if two players would read it differently, the roll can’t stand.

The cocked dice rule

The ruling almost every table uses: a cocked die doesn’t count. Pick up that die alone and roll it again. The other dice in the roll stand as they are. Don’t read the “most upward” face and don’t nudge it flat, because both let someone influence the result, even by accident.

Where the die stoppedUsual ruling
Flat on the table or tray, one face clearly upCounts. Read it.
Leaning on a book, a mini or a pencilCocked. Re-roll that die.
Resting on top of another dieCocked. Re-roll the top die; the one underneath counts if it’s flat.
Leaning against the wall of a dice trayUsually cocked. Some tables read it if the top face is obvious; agree which first.
Off the table or on the floorThe table’s call. Most groups re-roll it.

What does cocked mean in D&D?

The same thing: a die that lands at an angle, so you can’t tell which number is up. The D&D rulebooks don’t set a rule for cocked dice; like most table matters it’s left to the Dungeon Master, and almost every DM calls for a re-roll. The one thing to avoid is deciding after you’ve seen which number is nearly up, so settle it at session zero along with the rest of your dice etiquette.

How to tell if a die is cocked

  • The card test. If you could slide a playing card or a fingernail under one edge without the die toppling, it’s cocked.
  • The two-reader test. If two people looking from different seats would call a different number, it’s cocked.
  • Don’t touch it to check. Look first, decide, then pick it up. A die that falls flat because someone bumped the table has still been interfered with.

Common house rules

Re-rolling is the standard, but some groups prefer one of these. Any of them is fair, as long as everyone agrees before the dice come out:

  • “If it’s cocked, it’s a re-roll”: the standard, and the hardest to argue with.
  • “Tray walls count”: a die leaning on the tray wall is read if its top face is obvious, but anything resting on another object is re-rolled.
  • “Only the tray counts”: dice that leave the tray or land on anything but its floor are re-rolled, whatever they show.

How to stop dice landing cocked

  • Roll into a dice tray with a flat, felt-lined floor, so dice settle instead of skidding into things.
  • Keep the rolling area clear of books, minis, cups and phones.
  • Use a dice tower for contested rolls: the dice tumble out of the bottom into a clear tray.
  • Don’t roll a huge handful at once. Dice landing on each other are the most common cause; split big pools into two throws.

Digital dice

In Dice Drop, the 3D dice that settle in the open tray always come to rest flat. A die that ends up leaning against the tray wall is read from the face pointing most nearly upward, so every throw gives an answer and there’s nothing to argue over. It’s a handy way to settle a disputed roll, or to roll big handfuls without dice spilling everywhere.

Try it yourself. Throw real 3D physics dice in your browser, from the D1 to the D120, free.

🎲 Roll dice free

Keep reading: dice etiquette, the other table rules that keep every roll fair and undisputed.

Picture dice & Story board

Upload your own designs, or roll a story

Six die faces: a dragon and an arrow, then Gift, Trap, Miss and Star

Draw it, upload it, roll it. Put a sketch, your logo, your pet or your whole party on every face of a D2, D3 or D6, and roll dice nobody else has, in real 3D physics. Or open the free Story board: three dice that roll a place, a character and a problem, from a library of 90 pictures.

Four picture dice on the Dice Drop tray, showing the dragon, the arrow and more

More guides like this

All dice & game guides →